Skip to main content

Table 1 Studies included in the scoping review

From: Enhancing independent eating among older adults with dementia: a scoping review of the state of the conceptual and research literature

Focusa

Author(s), years, Country

Main purposes

Study design

Intervention(s) effectiveness

Watson, 1993 (UK) [6]

Issues in measuring feeding problems; direct and indirect interventions; measuring intervention effectiveness

Target population: older adults with dementia in any context

O + research agenda

Amella, 1998 (USA) [24]

Direct interventions (dietary needs) and indirect interventions (social, cultural, and interactive components of mealtime)

Target population: elderly individuals; special strategies for people with cognitive disabilities

O + clinical protocol

Manthorpe & Watson, 2003 (UK) [25]

A census of areas well-developed on feeding difficulties, as well as of areas with little knowledge and potential improvement

Target population: patients with dementia and their caregivers in any setting

Position paper + research agenda

Watson & Green, 2006 (UK) [26]

Interventions to promote oral nutritional intake

Target population: older people with dementia in any setting

SR

Aselage et al., 2011 (USA) [7]

Exploration of the state of the science related to assisted hand-feeding

Target population: people with dementia in NHs

O

Chang & Roberts, 2011 (USA) [27]

Areas of feeding difficulties (initiating feeding, maintaining attention, getting food into the mouth, chewing food and swallowing food); their specific manifestations, observable behaviour associated with each; multidisciplinary and feeding strategies documented as effective

Target population: patients with dementia in Hospitals and NHs

O

Hanson et al., 2011 (USA) [28]

Benefits of oral feeding options

Target population: people with dementia in LTC

SR

Jackson et al., 2011 (UK) [29]

Effectiveness of mealtime interventions

Target population: adults over the age of sixty with dementia living in any setting (no home)

SR

Abbot et al., 2013 (UK) [21]

Effectiveness of mealtime interventions

Target population: elderly individuals living in residential care, including also people with dementia

SR + MA

Liu et al., 2014 (USA) [10]

Effectiveness of interventions on mealtime difficulties

Target population: older people with dementia in any setting

SR

Bunn et al.,

2015 (UK) [30]

Effectiveness of interventions to increase fluid intake and reduce risk of dehydration

Target population: older adults who could drink living in residential, LTC special dementia units

SR

Douglas & Lawrence, 2015 (USA) [31]

Evaluate the research on environment-based interventions to improve nutritional status

Target population: older adult and people with dementia, with preference for those live in long-term settings

NR

Liu et al., 2015 (USA) [8]

Effectiveness of interventions on eating performance

Target population: older adults with dementia in LTC

SR

Abdelhamid et al., 2016 (UK) [12]

Effectiveness of direct interventions on food and fluid intake

Target population: older adults with dementia or with mild cognitive impairment in any setting

SR + MA

Bunn et al.,

2016 (UK) [32]

Effectiveness of direct interventions on food and fluid intake

Target population: older adults with dementia or with mild cognitive impairment in any setting

SR

Concept analysis

Chang & Roberts, 2008 (USA) [29]

Characteristics of eating difficulty, its antecedents and consequences providing direction for assessment and management

Target population: older adults with dementia in any setting

CA on SR

Aselage & Amella, 2010 (USA) [33]

Characteristics, antecedents and consequences of mealtime difficulties providing direction for assessment and management

Target population: older adults with dementia

CA

  1. aPrevailing aim of the review; CA concept analysis; LTC long term care; NH nursing home; NR narrative review; MA meta-analysis; O overview; ONS oral nutritional supplements; SR systematic review; UK United Kingdom; USA United States of America