Table 1 The characteristics of 18 studies included in this meta-analysis
From: The effect of psychological contract on turnover intention among nurses: a meta-analytic review
Study (first author, year, country) | Specialist department | Sample size (female/male) | Age (min~max) | Age ≤ 30 (%) | Permanent nurse (%) | Bachelor degree or above (%) | PC measure | TI measure | R (minimum value ~ maximum value) (the number of r were included in this review, including PC total and its dimensions and TI ) | R type | Quality |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Yang T T1, 2017 (China) | NA | 285 (285/0) | 21~30 | 100 | 5.96 | 22.46 | Li Y | Pei Y | -0.019 ~ -0.192 (9 r were included in this review ) | Pearson | 8 |
Li N, 2016 (China) | paediatric | 358 (285/0) | 20~55 | NA | 34.64 | 36.59 | Li Y | Li DR | -0.231~-0.484 (7 r were included in this review ) | Pearson | 8 |
Liu X X, 2013 (China) | nursing homes | 202 (NA/NA) | NA | 6.93 | 70.79 | 13.36 | Li Y | Li DR | -0.178 ~ -0.371 (7 r were included in this review ) | Pearson | 8 |
Yang T T2, 2016 (China) | NA | 583 (568/15) | ≤ 30 | 97.43 | 8.23 | 35.68 | Li Y | Pei Y | -0.084 ~ -0.301 (9 r were included in this review ) | Pearson | 8 |
Yu J, 2016 (China) | emergency | 120 (118/2) | 21~52 | NA | NA | 19.17 | Li Y | Li DR | -0.229 ~ -0.474 (7 r were included in this review ) | Pearson | 6 |
Zhou J, 2018 (China) | ICU | 221 (211/10) | NA | 76.92 | 12.22 | 57.47 | Chen FR | Li DR | 0.078 ~ 0.475 (9 r were included in this review ) | Pearson | 8 |
Guo X R, 2016 (China) | Mixed | 180 (NA/NA) | 20~49 | 76.11 | 0 | 56.67 | Chen FR | Wang YZ | 0.352 ~ 0.532 (8 rs were included in this review ) | Spearman | 8 |
Wu J, 2016 (China) | neurosurgery | 128 (128/0) | 19~54 | NA | 41.41 | 30.47 | Li Y | Li DR | -0.235 ~ -0.476 (7 r were included in this review ) | Pearson | 8 |
Li Y X, 2016 (China) | nursing homes | 1046 (873/173) | 19~62 | NA | NA | 0 | Li Y | Li DR | -0.232 ~ -0.465 (7 r were included in this review ) | Pearson | 8 |
Jin C Z, 2016 (China) | Mixed | 150 (NA/NA) | 20~55 | 18.67 | 0 | 60 | Chen FR | Wang YZ | 0.428 ~ 0.541 (8 r were included in this review ) | Pearson | 8 |
Chen F R, 2009 (China) | Mixed | 402 (402/0) | 20~59 | 38.81 | NA | 23.63 | Chen FR | FARH JL | 0.348 ~ 0.522 (8 rs were included in this review ) | Spearman | 7 |
Wang J, 2022 (China) | NA | 448 (354/94) | NA | 3.13 | NA | NA | Li Y | Li DR | -0.191 ~ -0.418 (7 r were included in this review ) | Pearson | 8 |
Chen N, 2015 (China) | oncology | 270 (268/2) | 22~48 | NA | 65.56 | 71.85 | Chen FR | self-designed | 0.342 ~ 0.452 (6 r were included in this review ) | Pearson | 6 |
Guo L, 2010 (China) | Mixed | 2865 (NA/NA) | NA | 46.18 | NA | NA | Chen FR | Wang YZ | -0.01 ~ 0.18 (6 r were included in this review ) | Pearson | 8 |
He X C, 2023 (China) | psychiatry | 285 (182/103) | NA | NA | 56.84 | 74.04 | Chen FR | Pei Y | 0.35 ~ 0.472 (7 r were included in this review ) | Pearson | 8 |
Feng Y, 2022 (China) | paediatric | 142 (NA/NA) | ≥ 20 | 5.6 | 4.23 | 21.13 | Li Y | Li DR | -0.621 ~ -0.701 (3 r were included in this review ) | Pearson | 6 |
M Takase, 2016 (Japan) | Mixed | 766 (701/65) | 22~62 | 50.65 | NA | NA | Maertz and Boyar | Maertz and Boyar | -0.54 | Pearson | 8 |
J Rodwell, 2016 (Australian) | Mixed | 457 (376/81) | 25~44 | NA | NA | NA | Robinson and Morrison | Chatman and Wayne | -0.16 ~ 0.51 (4 r were included in this review ) | Pearson | 8 |