Table 3 Ethical dilemma situation and court’s decision by cases
From: Is physical restraint unethical and illegal?: a qualitative analysis of Korean written judgments
Case | Case information | Ethical Dilemma Situation | Court’s Decision | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Place | Care recipient | Consequence | |||
A | Nursing home | Older adults with dementia (nasogastric tube, indwelling urinary catheter) | Nothing happened | 1 | Compliance |
B | Nursing home | Older adults with dementia | Fall | 1,2 | Compliance |
C | Nursing home | Older adults with dementia | Nothing happened | 1,2 | Compliance |
D | Nursing home | Older adults with dementia | Nothing happened | 3 | Violation |
E | Nursing home | Older adults with dementia (nasogastric tube, indwelling urinary catheter) | Nothing happened | 3 | Compliance |
F | Hospital | Older adults with deterioration of consciousness (peripheral intravenous line, arterial line) | Nothing happened | 3 | Compliance |