- Open Access
Fourth year intellectual disability student nurses’ journey and future work intention: a qualitative study
BMC Nursing volume 21, Article number: 220 (2022)
The aim of this qualitative study is to explore the views and experiences of final year BSc intellectual disability nursing students’ journey, future work plans and examine factors influencing their migration intentions following graduation.
A qualitative component of a mixed methods study where a focus group interview was conducted with final year BSc intellectual disability nursing students (n = 10) from one University in Ireland in June 2019. A topic guide was utilised, and participant’s were interviewed about their programme, future work plans and migration intentions. An inductive approach was utilised, and data were analysed using a pre-existing framework for initial coding and thematic development. Duffy’s conceptual model of identity transformation provided a structure to analyse the data and map themes onto the conceptual framework.
The findings were mapped onto the five stages of Duffy’s (2013) conceptual model of identity transformation: Pre-Entry; Reaffirming; Surmounting; Stabilising and Actualising. Findings indicate that further work is required to promote intellectual disability nursing and address professional esteem issues, support for education and professional development, such as providing career guidance opportunities prior to course completion, development of clinical skills within their education programme and support for the professional development of new graduates. Participant’s identified uncertainty about career opportunities and saw scope for future professional development opportunities particularly in community-based work.
This study has identified that final year intellectual disability nursing students are uncertain about career options and opportunities for intellectual disability nurses in other country’s. There is an urgent need for the intellectual disability nursing profession to articulate their practice and advocate for their role and contribution to the care of people with intellectual disability. This study identified a clear need for direction and information regarding intellectual disability nursing roles and career opportunities.
To provide high quality safe healthcare services, there is a need for sufficient appropriately trained staff to be in place at national, regional and local levels . However, global health workforce requirements are expected to increase in the coming years due to population growth, demographic and epidemiological factors [1, 2]. In this context, the World Health Organisation (WHO) predicts a global deficit of 18 million skilled health workers by 2030 . Many country’s are already experiencing challenges in the recruitment and retention of nurses, and this poses a significant strategic risk to the effective operation of a country’s health system in the coming years [3, 4]. In addressing these challenges each country’s national workforce planning strategic framework should encompass the WHO’s global code of practice on the international recruitment of health personnel principles . Therefore, country’s need to proactively plan and manage their health workforce demand and supply as far as possible. Part of this strategic planning process involves managing the migration of nurses and this must be balanced against healthcare professionals’ freedom to pursue work and the need to limit excessive losses to a profession or workforce.
Registered nurses in intellectual/learning disability provide health, wellbeing and social care supports to individuals with an intellectual disability . Ireland and the United Kingdom (UK) are the only two country’s specifically providing direct entry training programmes for intellectual/learning disability nurses , and therefore it may be anticipated that there would not be a retention or workforce issue. However, other factors such as staff stress and burnout, organisation culture, training and supervision  affect the retention of this specific discipline of nurses. Ireland and the UK have highly regarded nursing educational standards and given that English is the first language of students on these courses, there is a high international demand for graduate nurses from these jurisdictions and consequently a high level of opportunity for mobility .
Within published literature the definition of the term intellectual disability and an individual’s understanding of the label can be diverse . This diversity is reinforced by the fact that the term learning disability is used in the UK and other terms are used interchangeably such as developmental disability, intellectual developmental disorder, disorders of intellectual development, and intellectual and developmental disability. However, intellectual disability is the term of choice internationally and the disparity in the use of these labels poses challenges when comparing international research. Intellectual disability does not constitute a homogeneous group, however in terms of diagnosis and classification there are several features which have gained widespread acceptance irrespective of the terminology or definitions used. The three core criteria are: significant impairment of intellectual functioning; significant impairment of adaptive/social functioning and onset before adulthood.
International evidence recognises that people with intellectual disability have poorer health , greater health comorbidities , present more often for treatment , have more complex needs , experience increased polypharmacy  and die earlier  compared to the general population. Furthermore, healthcare services have been identified as ill-equipped to respond to the needs of a person with intellectual disability. There is evidence that people with intellectual disability receive poorer quality care , have more preventable illness , experience greater health disparities  and untreated health needs . This evidence highlights the need for an educated workforce with specific skills and training in intellectual disability. Intellectual disability nurses in Ireland and learning disability nurses in the UK have as a profession evolved over the last three decades in response to the changing landscape of service provision and in response to the complex healthcare needs of people with intellectual disability . Intellectual disability nurses possess a wide range of specialised skills to meet the varied health, behavioural, advocacy, and societal needs of persons with intellectual disability . Intellectual disability nurses meet the multifaceted healthcare needs of the person with intellectual disability through providing comprehensive care delivery and management that is appropriate to the individual through their specialised intellectual disability knowledge and skill . Intellectual disability nurses adapt their nursing skills for chronic health conditions experienced among people with intellectual disability including pneumonia, aspiration, dehydration, constipation, seizures, motor deficits, allergies, otitis media, gastroesophageal reflux disease, diabetes, dysmenorrhea, sleep disturbances, thyroid disorders, behavioural/mental health issues, vision and hearing impairments, and oral health problems .Intellectual disability nursing has adapted, reshaped and refocused the profession over the past three decades to respond to social, cultural, legal and moral drivers. Their role has often been questioned and often poorly understood and this stems from a move to a more social model and person-centred planning ideology . This role ambiguity has arisen as the social model, which underpins intellectual disability nursing, is perceived as the absence of nursing. Where in fact the social model within a healthcare context for people with intellectual disability is essential given their complex health needs, disparity in health and difficulties accessing mainstream healthcare. Consequently, the social model guides students to consider intellectual disability nursing within a wider society of supports, to challenge negative attitudes and prejudices that may exist and to consider the action required to address inequalities in health and to develop strategies to identify and support the person.
Although models of service provision for people with intellectual disability have changed and moved to more personalised services, there remains a requirement for an appropriately trained and skilled workforce . However, internationally the focus has shifted from specialised nurses to untrained support staff . The ongoing changes in service provision, questioning of need for a distinct intellectual disability nursing profession, along with the fact that intellectual disability services are marginalised and receive less research funding  often leads to internal and external questioning of the role of the intellectual disability nurse. This is evident within the UK where despite governmental commitment to the future of the learning disability nurse [28, 29], recruitment and retention issues exist with reducing numbers of learning disability nurses working in the National Health Service (NHS) [30, 31]. Recruitment and retention issues identified indicate anxiety about: the future of the profession , downgrading of the nursing workforce  and questioning the profession’s future as a separate field of nursing . In addition, the significance of public perceptions of intellectual disability nursing is a consideration  and the influence of societal stereotyped views of what a nurse is and does . The challenge of nursing staff turnover presents a significant barrier to building a specialised nursing workforce .
Given the fact that intellectual disability nurse training is only available in the UK and Ireland, the past and ongoing changes is service delivery models, the questioning of the intellectual disability nursing profession, and the multifaceted health and communication needs of persons with intellectual disability it is clear workforce planning needs to be a priority. Across nursing the shortage of nurses threaten the ability of health services to provide quality safe care [38, 39] and migration is a contributing factor to nursing/midwifery shortages . Identification of workforce planning, and retention strategies are paramount  however, this requires an understanding of factors influencing nurses’ decision to migrate and or take up employment in their home country. The transition from student to registered nurse is identified as a significant time point as turnover is high particularly in the first year following qualification . Staff turnover impacts on a healthcare organisation’s funding as it is expensive and time consuming to recruit new nurses into the workforce . However most importantly staff turnover impacts on the provision of quality and safe person-centred care, patient morbidity and mortality rates . Safe staffing levels are associated with improved outcomes including reduced medical and medication errors, decreased patient complications and mortality, improved patient satisfaction, reduced nurse fatigue and burnout and improved nurse retention and job satisfaction . The issues of recruitment and retention for this specialised field of nursing is important as little is known from an Irish perspective on the factors affecting recruitment and retention of intellectual disability nurses. Furthermore, it is valuable to consider recruitment and retention prior to graduation as it gives an opportunity to consider interventions that may influence recruitment and retention at the point of new graduates entering a workforce as one strategy to secure a sustainable workforce for the future . This paper aims to identify fourth year intellectual disability nursing students’ concept of intellectual disability nursing and employment intentions.
An explanatory concurrent mixed method research design was used to explore the migration intentions of fourth year graduating nursing and midwifery students in Ireland. The study was conducted in two phases and all data were collected between May and June 2019. Phase one of the study a survey of BSc nursing (general, mental health, intellectual disability) and BSc midwifery students is reported separately . This paper reports phase two, a focus group interview with intellectual disability nursing students (n = 10) in one higher education institution in Ireland to explore their journey and explain and expand upon factors that influence on their future work and migration intentions. A participant information leaflet (PIL) outlining the nature, aims and purpose of the study and an invitation to participate in both phases of the study was emailed to all fourth-year students. Students were advised that participation in one phase did not require participation in the second phase. A date and time for the focus group was arranged outside of class time and prior to the focus group, participant’s were given an additional PIL and asked to sign a consent form.
The study was set in one higher education institution involved in nursing and midwifery education in Ireland.
Ethical approval for the study was obtained from Education and Health Science Research Ethics Committee (2019_05_08_EHS) and permission to access was obtained from the department head. Participant’s (n = 10) were informed that confidentiality was a shared responsibility among focus group participant’s and were asked to sign a declaration of confidentiality to ensure that the discussion and identity of fellow participant’s would not be disclosed outside the focus group. Participation was voluntary and participant’s were informed that they could withdraw from the study at any time.
A total of ten students returned an expression of interest form indicating their willingness to participate in the focus groups and all participated in the study. The sample were all female ranging in age from 22 to 34 years. Three participant’s had accessed the programme via the mature entry route and the remainder were school leavers at the time of entry.
Focus groups were chosen for this phase of the research, after recruitment ten participant’s participated in one focus group which was conducted in a private room to facilitate a discussion among participant’s about their views and experiences around their intention following graduation, using a topic guide, developed from the literature and previous national survey . Open questions and follow up probes were used. The focus group lasted approximately 50 min and were audio-recorded with consent.
Transcripts were transcribed verbatim, anonymised, checked for accuracy and analysis performed utilising a form of ‘best fit’ framework analysis, where a pre-existing framework was used for initial coding and theme development. The framework utilised was based on Duffy’s conceptual model of identity transformation  which encompasses five stages: pre-entry, reaffirming, surmounting, stabilising and actualising. This analytic framework was chosen as it was developed through constructivist grounded theory techniques in an investigation of transition where participant’s conceptualised their personal and professional development identities over time. Utilising an inductive approach, data was coded and mapped onto the five stages of the conceptual framework by two authors (OD, LK) independently by reading and rereading the transcripts. The team met to discuss and confirm the mapping which is reported in the form of domain/theme, sub-theme/category and code/sub-category (Table 1) and supported by participant’s illustrative quotes in the results. Duffy’s conceptual model of identity transformation  provided a useful analytical structure to inform and shape an understanding of intellectual disability student nurses’ professional development and identity and migration intentions.
Analysed data were mapped onto the five stages of Duffy’s conceptual model of identify transformation  and presented under the following themes:
The theme of pre-entry was evident within the analysis stage when mapping the coded data and the subthemes of choice, exposure, prior knowledge and understanding were evident. Participant’s discussed their choice to enter nursing and while half of the participant’s had previous exposure to intellectual disability nursing it was not their first course choice or first nursing course choice and this resulted in students changing or leaving the course. However, while it may not have been a first choice for some, participant’s reported adjusting to the course and growing to love it.
“I just had to go into something …. I wanted the guards (Irish Police Force) but they hadn't recruited in a few years …. so I had to go into something, but it's been great, I love it …. three went to general and one left altogether”.
For those with prior exposure this helped them choose intellectual disability nursing and settle into their programme. Experience ranged from social contact through a drama group, to exposure during school placements or work experience and employment as a carer.
“I went to a unit within the service (names removed) …. we did a show with them in the (name removed) theatre …. I did get experience and I loved it …. I was care staff for a few years”.
Some students did not have any prior experience of intellectual disability nursing prior to accepting a place on the course and this was identified as a reason why some students left the programme. Participant’s suggested that exposure and experience would be beneficial to assist prospective students to be informed of the course and consider intellectual disability nursing as a career choice.
“Get experience first, cos how many people did we lose in the first year …. I'd say work as care staff for a while first”.
Prior knowledge and understanding of intellectual disability nursing was seen as essential to retention of students on the course. Participant’s who stayed on the programme had obtained information about the programme prior to choosing the course through schools and friends.
“I found out about it in school …. one of my friends was a year above me and she did this course, so she'd give me information about it”.
However, some knew very little about the programme and articulated they were entering blind but there was a need to just choose something. Regardless for those who remained on the course they found it enjoyable.
“I knew nothing about it until I went into it …. I went into it blind …. I just had to go into something, I didn't know what I was going into, but it's been a lovely course”.
The theme of reaffirming was evident within the analysis stage when mapping the coded data. The coded data all mapped onto the subtheme of belonging and participant’s described ‘a sense of belonging’ developed through engagement with a variety of placements provided across intellectual disability and other nursing care settings during their programme. Such placements created a sense of settling in, however, while variety was seen as positive this was finely balanced by the fact that many placements were of a short duration.
“We'd have done various placements but only a few weeks at the most in each …. you can be working in the community, in family homes, in residential care …. and we did weeks in general, paediatrics, mental health”.
The variation offered in clinical placements sites assisted students to change their views on intellectual disability nursing as a career choice.
“If I was asked that a couple of years ago, I would have said Acute setting was what I wanted but not now…. I'd rather community setting”.
A key aspect of reaffirming was the development of participant’s identity as an intellectual disability nurse and part of this identity formation involved reconciling misconceptions of this minority discipline of nursing.
“It is a level 8, you know that it is a degree, and we are nurses we do all the other things other nurses do”.
Existing nurses had a key role in forming participant’s identity through engagement and mentorship. However, a negative aspect in identity formation were existing staff’s sense of value and commitment to their profession and their uncertainty led to participant’s questioning their value rather that consolidated it.
“You walk in, and a nurse is asking you questions keeping you on your toes …. but if you're working with someone who is fed up with their own job, they're going to tell you to get out …. but the whole RNID degree is about holistic care, and you know it is a different attitude and that’s important”.
The theme of surmounting was evident within the analysis stage when mapping the coded data formed the subthemes of placement and challenges and limitations. Most of participant’s placements were in residential settings and participant’s were aware of the landscape shift of service to the community for people with intellectual disability and were surprised there were not more community placements.
“The majority of it you could say that 80% of it has been in residential settings …. I'm surprised there isn't more placement community based …. but I've been in two community houses back-to-back, two months and two months”.
While placements were predominantly in residential setting participant’s developed through learning on the job. However, a need for a greater focus on clinical skills development in the University setting was identified to enable participant’s gain greater confidence.
“There’s hands on learning all the time when you’re on placement … and most of it has been in a residential setting and that's the only limit I think but clinical skills, we don't get enough clinical skills experience or teaching …. we only got an hour on injections, and we did that when in second year …. I know you're going to learn on the job as well but there needs to be more practical skills and OSCE’s …. you'd get it but not enough to be confident”.
Key to surmounting challenges was assuming leadership in one’s own learning.
“It's very hard sometimes to say can I do the medications with you because there's not enough people on the floor but once you just say it to them you do get more experience with medications, and they will let you help and let you get your experience with medications.
The theme of stabilising was evident within the analysis stage when mapping the coded data. The coded data all mapped onto the subtheme of developing where exposure to clinical practice and experience enabled participant’s create their identity and stabilise their understanding of their role. The changing landscape of service provision meant that students were exposed to a variety of care models with a holistic care approach evident across services.
“We have the clinical, certain residential settings would be more clinical so you’re learning on the job you'd have like PEG experience …. we do all the other things that nurses do and it’s a holistic approach to like you know fulfilling somebody's life …. one community house is like the dream of community living and the other one can be all clinical or have extremely challenging behaviour and be very limited for the service users and it's opened my eyes to the congregated settings, it's not all black and white”.
While participant’s programme of study and placement were rewarding, they also created additional interests for consideration of their future careers related to intellectual disability or nursing.
“I'd love to do teaching, I'd love to teach kids with an intellectual disability or go to (named place) and do my children's nursing”.
One issue of concern to participant’s was the aspect of role clarity which they had to address within themselves during their programme.
“When we're on placement, and you're supposed to be getting nurse experience, but you do end up being the care staff, your kind of maybe on the floor while they're getting things done or doing their work”.
The theme of actualising was evident within the analysis stage when mapping the coded data formed the subthemes of unpredictability, new future and opportunity, and travel and mobility. Given the uncertainty and direction from intellectual disability nursing leadership regarding the transition of intellectual disability nurses within the changing landscape of service provision participant’s articulated concerns regarding limited job opportunity and job security.
“They have trained us for four years and there's not one job opportunity for us, at the moment anyway… It's kind of just a kick in the teeth then if they're not even offering one of us a job, you'd think they might have a few posts going …. a few years ago, they gave five jobs to one year but then they let them go again”.
Participant’s expressed insecurity regarding the recognition of the intellectual disability nurse’s role internationally which may limit opportunities to secure employment in other country’s.
“But intellectual disability nursing it’s not recognised in places like America is it”.
Participant’s identified a clear need for direction and information regarding their role and career opportunities within Ireland.
“We don't know where it's going, you have to work a little bit harder and figure it out, it would be helpful for someone to sit down and actually tell us the possibilities for our future like I imagine someone coming in and saying you can actually do this or you can do this, there should be always someone you can go to like a manager or someone senior to you so if you are not sure of something that you can go to them”.
However, participant’s also saw opportunities in their nursing career pathway and role development.
“I think as it moves out to community that there's going to be a need for community CNS's (clinical nurse specialists) and community CNM’s (clinical nurse managers) and we'll be like public health nurses but for intellectual disability …. CNS’s and ANP's (advanced nurse practitioners) that's where I hope we're going …. the RNID (registered nurse intellectual disability) is overseeing care, interventions are signed up and written up by the nurse and if someone needs to go and have their medication's reviewed then a nurse will step in or if something needs support the nurse will step in”.
“For me there is a need around nutrition and also palliative care, we will be more clinical as well as we move out to community …. out in the community not in a residential setting, I'm hoping that's the future”.
To actualise their role fully some participant’s saw a need to further develop their nursing through a dual qualification. However, there was also a desire to do other healthcare professional training and leave nursing.
“I would like have a dual qualification, I’d do my children's nursing, or I'd like to do occupational therapy or do speech and language”.
However, many want to stay within intellectual disability services but would like to diversify and compliment their nursing role.
“I'd like to still work in the intellectual disability sector, but just do something a bit different …. I'd like to do dietetics in a post grad, but that's for CNS, I still want to work in intellectual disability …. I'd love to teach kids with an intellectual disability”.
Part of the actualising process was the realisation of the role, expectations of the role and the need to transition from student to staff.
“You have to have to get at least six months work experience they expect so much when we qualify, the first six months as an actual staff nurse you will learn so much, we will be actually doing it yourself, being responsible for it as well …. medications will be a big thing but once you get into the mind frame, you're a qualified staff nurse we'll be fine”.
Participant’s expressed a clear desire to travel now or soon, and their plans were affected by what they understood as requirements in other country’s.
“Most places require experience, if you're applying for Australia, you need a year's experience in Ireland, I'm going to Australia to work I'd love to go after a few years”.
For participant’s there was a lack of clarity regarding intellectual disability nursing in other country’s as only Ireland and the United Kingdom have a recognised division on the register.
“It's not recognised in places like America …. there's some country’s I think you can work as a psychiatric or registered nurse”.
Participant’s desire to travel was based on positive feedback from others and the fact that other friends had gone.
“We've heard a lot of good feedback from older nurses that have gone and come back and there’s nurses that are gone and still out there, you'd hear feedback from there and from your friends”.
The allure of travel was reinforced by what were perceived as a more positive work environment.
“It's so positive like there's such a positive working environment, it's quite appealing”.
However, some participant’s had to stay in Ireland due to family while other anticipated coming back in a few years. One participant intended to remain working abroad.
“At the end of the day your family is still here, I'm a home bird, I want to go but I would come back, give me two, three years over there and then I would come back well I don't know even if I came home for Christmas”.
The findings of this study indicate that further work is needed in; promoting intellectual disability nursing as a career choice, addressing professional esteem issues, support for educational and professional identity development during training programmes, providing career guidance opportunities prior to course completion and supporting the professional development of new graduates. In addition, while the findings of this study relate to intellectual disability, they may resonate across other nursing and midwifery disciplines and have implications for undergraduate and postgraduate education.
A key finding of this study was that some students choose intellectual disability nursing without knowing what it entails, had no experience to draw on and it was not their first career choice. In some instances, this resulted in students leaving the programme or transferring to another nursing programme. Consideration needs to be given to providing prospective students with opportunities to gain insight to the discipline of intellectual disability nursing through university open days, information on university websites and through social media. There is a need to rethink intellectual disability curricula to address the esteem issues raised by participant’s. Consideration needs to be given to facilitating nursing students in professional identity development through e.g., adjusting curricula content to include, the history of intellectual disability nursing, developing clinical skills and addressing identity and socialisation into the profession. Within this study participant’s identified their needs in terms of clinical skills development, and this should be considered in terms of future proofing the discipline of intellectual disability nursing [45, 46]. Professional identity is identified as the values and beliefs possessed by the nurse that guide his/her thinking, actions, and interactions with a patient . Addressing professional identity may also address role ambiguity which often occurs when nursing students are unclear of their responsibilities or receive unclear information regarding the nursing student role. In this study some students felt that while they were on clinical placement they were fulfilling a care staff role rather than that of a student nurse focused on learning, development of skills and linking theory to practice and this finding may translate across nursing and midwifery programmes internationally as the focus can be on doing as opposed to the student learning opportunities and outcomes.
Through addressing professional identify issues nursing students can learn about the values and ethics of the profession, develop greater understanding of their role and their personal identification as a professional within an identified professional group . Addressing a disciplines professional identify may address attrition rates and reduce turnover rate  and hold relevance across all areas of nursing and midwifery. In addition, other factors reported as contributing to attrition need to be considered such as; academic failure, personal/family difficulties, nursing as a wrong career choice, financial difficulties , disappointed dreams and lack of academic support [51, 52].
Because professional identity and the historical context of intellectual disability nursing are inextricably linked it is important to address this in the undergraduate curricula . Intellectual disability nursing has operated on the fringes of nursing and has even been described as marginalised within the profession [21, 54,55,56,57]. Therefore, it is essential that intellectual disability nursing students develop a sense of belonging within the wider field of nursing, through the application of the unique knowledge, skills, values and culture of intellectual disability nursing while actively engaging in practice [58,59,60]. Furthermore, the professional identity may be eroded by the focus of governmental funding to service providers based on a social model and the lack of appreciation of how the social model can underpin intellectual disability nursing care and support delivery . Developing a sense of belonging is synonymous with developing a sense of confidence and professionalism  and within practice students’ need to feel part of a team  rather than on the fringes, as clinical practice and learning experiences are linked to student satisfaction [63, 64]. A positive clinical learning environment fosters student progression and retention through facilitating their learning and identity as a nurse [65, 66] and reducing role uncertainty. Fundamental within this process it the recognition of the need for and value of intellectual disability nurses, where intellectual disability nurses are direct care experts, care coordinators, interprofessional collaborators, and advocates and leaders for equitable care . Care is provided within a relationship-based, lifespan approach and intellectual disability nurses possess a unique relational skill set  characterized by a strong nurse-client relationship  that assists people with intellectual disability live and access healthy lives .
Undergraduate nurse education aims to develop competent, confident and effective professionals through education, socialisation and professional identity . Developing professional identity is a core aspect of nursing that effects self-efficacy (confidence in accomplishing tasks), outcome expectation (benefits of working in the profession)  and professional commitment . Poor socialisation can lead to negative professional identity , insufficient engagement  and hinder professional practice behaviour . These aspects affect the ability to retain students upon course completion and influence their intention to leave [72, 73]. This loss of new graduate nurses is undesirable given the global demand for nurses  and nursing shortages . Indeed, the recent World’s Nursing Report reveals a significant lack of nursing staff , likely to be even further exacerbated by the COVID-19 pandemic.
Within this study the professional identity of intellectual disability nursing was often questioned by participant’s and this maybe reflective of an exposure to or apathy observed by student nurses in practice, within existing registered intellectual disability nurses. This apathy in part may be due to registered nurses’ insecurity about their own professional identity, landscape changes within service provision and the ambiguity of their role created because of these changes . However, lessons learned from COVID-19 highlight stress and burnout due to staffing shortages, the emotional toll of caring, illness, and feeling devalued . Within intellectual disability this is further emphasised by the ambiguous role of intellectual disability nurses, deinstitutionalization, diverse practice settings, different models of care delivery and policies . Thus, this has resulted in a cautious approach by disability providers to include nursing, fearing that intellectual disability nurses would medicalize the everyday lives of people with intellectual disability . As a profession intellectual disability nurses need to make their contribution visible [7, 81] as they have been described as a shy discipline lacking a strong voice in articulating and explaining their role . To progress and address this matter, both undergraduate and postgraduate educational programmes and the profession of intellectual disability nurses internationally need to address professional identify, the landscape of service provision models of care and professional advocacy.
A recent review of intellectual disability nursing in Ireland  articulates a clear role and focus for the intellectual disability nurse in Ireland and the timing is right to reinvigorate the profession and make its contribution visible . Professional identity is formed through an interactive network and a student’s experience in the clinical learning environment may affect professional identity development . Other factors, such as age, gender, educational background and family income have also been identified as contributing factors. Nevertheless, it is through socialisation that a professional identity develops [86, 87] and both education and clinical placements are both major contributing factors in providing authentic learning and professional identity development opportunities [88, 89]. A key feature is the duration, quality and quantity of clinical placements which are linked to student satisfaction, their sense of belonging and professional identity [86, 90, 91]. Currently within the Irish nurse education system students undertake 63 weeks theoretical instruction and 81 weeks clinical instruction/internship and both elements are required to meet the nurse registration programmes standards and requirements  to be approved and accredited by the nursing and midwifery board of Ireland. The importance of nurses in clinical practice as role models during clinical placements and nurse academics as role models in the education setting cannot be underestimated as role modelling is an integral aspect of professional socialisation and occurs in all facets of the authentic learning journey . In addition, research and collaboration across countries needs to be undertaken to identify and debate what is known about intellectual disability nursing internationally and beyond that of the country’s specifically providing direct entry training programmes (Ireland and the UK).
In this study participant’s were uncertain of career options and of opportunities for intellectual disability nursing in other country’s. This uncertainty of career options could be a factor influencing the retention of intellectual disability nurses and given that large numbers of students on the programme had prior experience and choose intellectual disability nursing there should be a positive attitude and a desire to remain in nursing related paid employment . To further address the uncertainty within the discipline of intellectual disability nursing there needs to be a clear articulation of the implementation plan based on the outcomes of the national review of the future role of intellectual disabilities nurses in Ireland . Furthermore, there is a need for a commitment from intellectual disability services within the national health service executive and outside (voluntary organisations) to the enactment of the implementation plan, continuous professional development of staff and advancement of the intellectual disability nursing profession. At an individual level intellectual disability nurses need to advocate for their role, articulate their practice and engage in on-going professional development and education. In this study participant’s expressed a desire for continuing professional education and career advancement, such desires are in line with national policy such as the policy on the development of graduate to advanced nursing and midwifery practice  and Sláintecare citizen care masterplan  which both support the effective use of intellectual disability nurses through service redesign based on population health planning, current levels of service delivery and the development of accessible healthcare services for people with intellectual disability.
Given that intellectual disability operates on the fringes of the nursing profession and that the size of the specialty of intellectual disability nursing accounts for just 6.75% of the nursing profession  there is a need for national leadership from within the profession, health service providers and health agency. Given the evidence of the complex health needs, access issues and health disparities of people with intellectual disability it is essential that we recruit and retain nurses with specialised unique knowledge and skills, and competence to work with people with intellectual disability [98,99,100].
This study highlights issues specific to intellectual disability nursing and as with any research the results have to be considered in the context of the study and limitations which include a small sample which was from one educational institute in Ireland. Additional research is required to identify the transferability of the findings and a longitudinal study within student training and post qualification is warranted given the anticipated workforce issues of recruitment, retention and existing workforce shortage. Previous research examining the work intentions of intellectual disability nursing students is limited and this paper adds to existing knowledge by providing a rich and detailed picture of personal, social and professional drivers.
Intellectual disability service provision is in a time of major change for people with intellectual disabilities in Ireland . This change and reconfiguring in the absence of a clear pathway for the intellectual disability nurse role within primary and community care teams creates confusion and role ambiguity. Growing numbers of social care workers are now recruited into the intellectual disability sector with demand outstriping supply , while important for care provision social care workers cannot replace the clinical care an intellectual disability nurse can provide. While there has been a national review of intellectual disability nursing which highlights the need for intellectual disability nurses , there is a vacuum which has been created in the absence of a visible and communicated plan for the professional work group. Such an absence seems to be creating an apathy and uncertainty regarding intellectual disability nursing. In addition, the absence of national identifiable intellectual disability nurse leaders and awareness of their role is affecting the level of undergraduate students’ entering and remaining in the intellectual disability nursing profession. Within the intellectual disability nursing students, the current ambiguity is affecting their future career choices and visions for nursing careers. Where some can see a pathway to advanced and community practice, others question the opportunities available and development of the profession that will occur if they stay within the profession.
Availability of data and materials
Data will not be shared due to difficulties in the anonymization of qualitative data as participant’s within this study shared their views and experiences with the assurance that their confidentiality and anonymity would be protected. Hence, the research data is not available publicly because this would compromise individual privacy and our ethical approval conditions. If you have a data request you may contact the lead author Dr Owen Doody at firstname.lastname@example.org.
Bachelor of Science
National Health Service (UK)
Participant Information Leaflet
World Health Organisation
Department of Health. Working together for health: A national strategic framework for health and social care workforce planning. Dublin: Department of Health; 2017.
World Health Organization. Global strategy on human resources for health: workforce 2030. Geneva: World Health Organization; 2016.
Buchan J, Charlesworth A, Gershlick B, Seccombe I. A critical moment: NHS staffing trends, retention and attrition. London: Health Foundation; 2019.
Drennan VM, Ross F. Global nurse shortages: The facts, the impact and action for change. Brit Med Bull. 2019;130(1):25–37.
World Health Organisation. WHO Global Code of Practice on the International Recruitment of Health Personnel. Geneva: World Health Organisation; 2010.
McCarron M, Sheerin F, Roche L, Ryan AM, Griffiths C, Keenan P, Doody O, D’Eath M, Burke E, McCallion P. Shaping the future of intellectual disability nursing in Ireland. Dublin: Health Services Executive; 2018.
Doody O, Murphy F, Lyons R, Gallen A, Ryan J, Downey J, Sezgin D. Development of nursing quality care process metrics and indicators for intellectual disability services: a literature review and modified Delphi consensus study. BMC Health Serv Res. 2019;19(1):909.
McKenzie K, Metcalfe D, Whelan K, McNall A. Improving recruitment and retention in learning disability services. Nurs Times. 2021;117(4):26–9.
Deasy C, O Loughlin C, Markey K, O Donnell C, Murphy Tighe S, Doody O, Tuohy D, Hussey M, O’Brien B, Meskell P. Effective workforce planning: Understanding final-year nursing and midwifery students’ intentions to migrate after graduation. J Nurs Manage. 2021;29(2):220–8.
Griffiths P, Bennett J, Smith E. The research base for learning disability nursing: a rapid scoping review. London: Nursing Research Unit, King’s College London; 2007.
Young-Southward G, Rydzewska E, Philo C, Cooper SA. Physical and mental health of young people with and without intellectual disabilities: cross-sectional analysis of a whole country population. J Intellect Disabil Res. 2017;61(10):984–93.
Startin CM, D’Souza H, Ball G, Hamburg S, Hithersay R, Hughes KM, Massand E, Karmiloff-Smith A, Thomas MS, Strydom A. Health comorbidities and cognitive abilities across the lifespan in Down syndrome. J Neurodev Disord. 2020;12(1):1–3.
Stancliffe RJ, Durvasula S, Wilson NJ, Lewis P. Treatment engagement and people with intellectual disability. In: Hadler A, Sutton S, Osterberg L. The Wiley handbook of healthcare treatment engagement: Theory, research, and clinical practice. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley Blackwell; 2020. p. 381–98.
Wark S, Kingstone M. The complexity of lifelong comorbidities with severe intellectual disability. J Intellect Dev Dis. 2019;44(4):431–8.
Selph C, Cosca B. Less is more: preventing polypharmacy in individuals with intellectual disabilities. Impact. 2016;29:28–9.
O’Leary L, Cooper SA, Hughes-McCormack L. Early death and causes of death of people with intellectual disabilities: a systematic review. J Appl Res Intellect. 2018;31(3):325–42.
Ailey SH, Brown PJ, Ridge CM. Improving hospital care of patients with intellectual and developmental disabilities. Disabil Health J. 2017;10(2):169–72.
Trollor J, Srasuebkul P, Xu H, Howlett S. Cause of death and potentially avoidable deaths in Australian adults with intellectual disability using retrospective linked data. BMJ Open. 2017;7(2):e013489.
Sabatello M. Precision medicine, health disparities, and ethics: the case for disability inclusion. Genet Med. 2018;20(4):397–9.
Durbin A, Sirotich F, Lunsky Y, Durbin J. Unmet needs of adults in community mental health care with and without intellectual and developmental disabilities: a cross-sectional study. Community Ment Health J. 2017;53(1):15–26.
Doody O, Slevin E, Taggart L. The development of clinical nurse specialists (CNSs) in intellectual disability nursing in Ireland. J Intellect Disabil. 2012;16(3):163–72.
Auberry K. Intellectual and developmental disability nursing: current challenges in the USA. Nursing Res Rev. 2018;8:23–8.
Doody O, Hennessy T, Bright AM. The role and key activities of Clinical Nurse Specialists and Advanced Nurse Practitioners in supporting healthcare provision for people with intellectual disability: An integrative review. Int J Nurs Stud. 2022;129:104207.
Doody O, Ryan R, McMahon J, Lyons R, Moloney M, Hennessy T. Presenting problem/conditions that result in people with an intellectual disability being admitted to acute hospitals in Ireland: An analysis of NQAIS data from 2016–2020. Limerick: University of Limerick and Office of the Nursing and Midwifery Service Director, Health Service Executive; 2021.
Sanderson H, Lewis J. A practical guide to delivering personalisation. Person-centred practice in health and social care. London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers; 2012.
Mansel J. Raising our sights: services for adults with profound intellectual and multiple disabilities. The Tizard Centre: University of Kent; 2010.
Furst MA, Salvador-Carulla L. Intellectual disability in Australian nursing education: experiences in NSW and Tasmania. J Intellec Dev Dis. 2019;44(3):357–66.
Scottish Government. Strengthening the Commitment: The report of the UK Modernising Learning Disabilities Nursing Review. Edinburgh: Scottish Government; 2012.
Department of Health. Strengthening the Commitment: One year on. London: Department of Health; 2014.
Glover G, Emerson E. Patterns of decline in numbers of learning disability nurses employed by the English National Health Service. Tizard Learn Dis Rev. 2012;17(4):194–8.
Royal College of Nursing. Connecting for change: for the future of learning disability nursing. Lindon: Royal College of Nursing; 2021.
Owen S, Standen P. Attracting and retaining learning disability student nurses. Brit J Learn Disabil. 2007;35(4):261–8.
Royal College of Nursing. Connect for Change: an update on learning disability services in England. London: Royal College of Nursing; 2016.
Nursing and Midwifery Council. The code: Professional standards of practice and behaviour for nurses and midwives. London: Nursing and Midwifery Council; 2015.
Genders N, Brian B. Who chooses to be a nurse, and why. Learn Disabil Pract. 2014;17(1):14–8.
Cameron J, Roxburgh M, Taylor J, Lauder W. Why students leave in the UK: an integrative review of the international research literature. J Clin Nurs. 2011;20(7–8):1086–96.
Brook J, Aitken L, Webb R, MacLaren J, Salmon D. Characteristics of successful interventions to reduce turnover and increase retention of early career nurses: A systematic review. Int J Nurs Stud. 2019;91:47–59.
Both-Nwabuwe JMC, Djkstra MTM, Klink A, Beersma B. Maldistribution or sacristy of nurses? The devil is in the detail. J Nurs Manage. 2018;26:86–93.
Nedvědová D, Dušová B, Jarošová D. Job satisfaction of midwives: A literature review. Cent Eur J Nurs Midwifery. 2017;8:650–6.
Gea-Caballero V, Castro-Sánchez E, Díaz-Herrera MÁ, Sarabia-Cobo C, Juárez-Vela R, Zabaleta-Del OE. Motivations, beliefs, and expectations of Spanish nurses planning migration for economic reasons: A cross-sectional, web-based survey. J Nurs Scholarsh. 2019;51:178–86.
Blegen A, Spector N, Lynn M, Barnsteiner J, Ulrich B. Newly licensed RN retention. Hospital and nurse characteristics. J Nurs Adm. 2017;47:508–14.
Zander B, Aiken LH, Busse R, Rafferty AM, Sermeus W, Bruyneel L. The state of nursing in the European Union. EuroHealth. 2016;22(1):3–6.
Shimp KM. Systematic review of turnover/retention and staff perception of staffing and resource adequacy related to staffing. Nurs Econ. 2017;35(5):239-258,266A.
Duffy R. Nurse to educator: Academic roles and the formation of personal academic identities. Nurse Educ Today. 2013;33(6):620–4.
Bennett LL. The gap between nursing education and clinical skills. ABNF J. 2017;28(4):96–102.
Saylor J, Hertsenberg L, McQuillan M, O’Connell A, Shoe K, Calamaro CJ. Effects of a service learning experience on confidence and clinical skills in baccalaureate nursing students. Nurs Educ Today. 2018;61:43–8.
Simmonds A, Nunn A, Gray M, Hardie C, Mayo S, Peter E, Richards J. Pedagogical practices that influence professional identity formation in baccalaureate nursing education: A scoping review. Nurs Educ Today. 2020;93:104516.
Fitzgerald A. Professional identity: A concept analysis. Nurs Forum. 2020;55(3):447–72.
Browne C, Wall P, Batt S, Bennett R. Understanding perceptions of nursing professional identity in students entering an Australian undergraduate nursing degree. Nurse Educ Pract. 2018;32:90–6.
Urwin S, Stanley R, Jones M, Gallagher A, Wainwright P, Perkins A. Understanding student nurse attrition: Learning from the literature. Nurs Educ Today. 2010;30(2):202–7.
Glew PJ, Ramjan LM, Salas M, Raper K, Creed H, Salamonson Y. Relationships between academic literacy support, student retention and academic performance. Nurs Educ Pract. 2019;39:61–6.
Ten Hoeve Y, Castelein S, Jansen G, Roodbol P. Dreams and disappointments regarding nursing: Student nurses’ reasons for attrition and retention. A qualitative study design. Nurs Educ Today. 2017;54:28–36.
Shahidi LH, Vahidi M, Mahram B, Areshtanab HN, Zarghi N. Professional identity development in nursing students: Eisner’s evaluation model. Res Dev Med Educt. 2014;3(1):37–43.
Gates B, Griffiths C, Atherton HL, McAnelly S, Keenan P, Fleming S, Doyle C, Cleary M, Sutton P. Intellectual disability nursing: An oral history project. Bingley: Emerald Group Publishing; 2020.
Sweeney J, Mitchell D. A challenge to nursing: an historical review of intellectual disability nursing in the UK and Ireland. J Clin Nurs. 2009;18(19):2754–63.
Mitchell D. Learning disability nursing. Brit J Learn Disabil. 2004;32(3):115–8.
Mitchell D. Parallel stigma: Nurses and people with learning disabilities. Brit J Learn Disabil. 2000;28(2):78–81.
Dinmohammadi M, Peyrovi H, Mehrdad N. Concept analysis of professional socialization in nursing. Nurs Forum. 2013;48(1):26–34.
Trede F, Macklin R, Bridges D. Professional identity development: a review of the higher education literature. Stud High Educ. 2012;37(3):365–84.
Walker S, Dwyer T, Broadbent M, Moxham L, Sander T, Edwards K. Constructing a nursing identity within the clinical environment: The student nurse experience. Contemp Nurse. 2014;49(1):103–12.
Del Prato D. Students’ voices: the lived experience of faculty incivility as a barrier to professional formation in associate degree nursing education. Nurs Educ Today. 2013;33(3):286–90.
Boardman G, Lawrence K, Polacsek M. Undergraduate student nurses’ perspectives of an integrated clinical learning model in the mental health environment. Int J Ment Health Nu. 2019;28(1):96–104.
Edwards H, Smith S, Courtney M, Finlayson K, Chapman H. The impact of clinical placement location on nursing students’ competence and preparedness for practice. Nurs Educ Today. 2004;24:248–55.
Bos E, Alinaghizadeh H, Saarikoski M, Kaila P. Factors associated with student learning processes in primary health care units: A questionnaire study. Nurs Educ Today. 2015;35(1):170–5.
Levett-Jones T, Lathlean J. Belongingness: a prerequisite for nursing students’ clinical learning. Nurs Educ Pract. 2008;8:103–11.
Chesser-Smyth PA. The lived experiences of general student nurses on their first clinical placement: a phenomenological study. Nurse Educ Pract. 2005;5:320–7.
Association DDN. Practice standards of developmental disability nursing. 3rd ed. Joliet, Illinois: High Tide Press; 2020.
Wilson NJ, Wiese M, Lewis P, Jaques H, O’Reilly K. Nurses working in intellectual disability-specific settings talk about the uniqueness of their role: A qualitative study. J Adv Nurs. 2019;75(4):812–22.
Desroches M. Nurses’ attitudes, beliefs, and emotions toward caring for adults with intellectual disabilities: An integrative review. Nurs Forum. 2020;55(2):211–22.
Desroches ML, Ailey S, Fisher K, Stych J. Impact of COVID-19: Nursing challenges to meeting the care needs of people with developmental disabilities. Disabil Health J. 2021;14(1):101015.
Thungjaroenkul P, Cummings GG, Tate K. Testing the social cognitive career theory in Thai nurses’ interest to become nurse educators: A structural equation modeling analysis. Nurs Educ Today. 2016;44:151–6.
Chênevert D, Jourdain G, Vandenberghe C. The role of high-involvement work practices and professional self-image in nursing recruits’ turnover: A three-year prospective study. Int J Nurs Stud. 2016;53:73–84.
Sabanciogullari S, Dogan S. Relationship between job satisfaction, professional identity and intention to leave the profession among nurses in Turkey. J Nurs Manage. 2015;23(8):1076–85.
Moloney W, Boxall P, Parsons M, Cheung G. Factors predicting Registered Nurses’ intentions to leave their organization and profession: A job demands-resources framework. J Adv Nurs. 2018;74(4):864–75.
Spence Laschinger HK, Zhu J, Read E. New nurses’ perceptions of professional practice behaviours, quality of care, job satisfaction and career retention. J Nurs Manage. 2016;24(5):656–65.
World Health Organization. Report of the policy dialogue meeting on the nursing workforce. Geneva: World Health Organization; 2017.
McCarthy C, Boniol M, Daniels K, Cometto G, Diallo K, Lawani AD, Campbell J. State of the World’s Nursing 2020: Investing in education, jobs, and leadership. Geneva: World Health Organization; 2020.
Doody O, Slevin E, Taggart L. A survey of nursing and multidisciplinary team members’ perspectives on the perceived contribution of intellectual disability clinical nurse specialists. J Clin Nurs. 2019;28(21–22):3879–89.
White EM, Wetle TF, Reddy A, Baier RR. Front-line Nursing Home Staff Experiences During the COVID-19 Pandemic. J Am Med Dir Assoc. 2021;22(1):199–203.
Desroches ML, Fisher K, Ailey S, Stych J, McMillan S, Horan P, Marsden D, Trip H, Wilson N. Supporting the needs of people with intellectual and developmental disabilities 1 year into the COVID-19 pandemic: An international, mixed methods study of nurses’ perspectives. J Policy Pract Intellect Disabil. 2022;19(1):48–63.
Doody O, Hennessy T, Moloney M, Lyons R, Bright AM. The value and contribution of intellectual disability nurses/nurses caring for people with intellectual disability in intellectual disability settings: A scoping review. J Clin Nurs. 2022;00:1–48. https://doi.org/10.1111/jocn.16289.
Martin AM, Connor-Fenelon MO, Lyons R. Non-verbal communication between Registered Nurses Intellectual Disability and people with an intellectual disability: an exploratory study of the nurse’s experiences. Part 2. J Intellect Disabil. 2012;16(2):97–108.
Doody O, Lyons R, Ryan R. The experiences of adults with intellectual disability in the involvement of nursing care planning in health services. Brit J Learn Disabil. 2019;47(4):233–40.
Nepal B, Taketomi K, Ito YM, Kohanawa M, Kawabata H, Tanaka M, Otaki J. Nepalese undergraduate nursing students’ perceptions of the clinical learning environment, supervision and nurse teachers: A questionnaire survey. Nurs Educ Today. 2016;39:181–8.
Wang YZ, Zhang HJ, Huang AH, Chen S, Xing JH, Chen LL. Research progress of professional identity status among domestic nursing students. Chinese Nursi Manage. 2014;14(12):1339–41.
Marañón AA, Pera MP. Theory and practice in the construction of professional identity in nursing students: a qualitative study. Nurs Educ Today. 2015;35(7):859–63.
Moreland JJ, Ewoldsen DR, Albert NM, Kosicki GM, Clayton MF. Predicting nurses’ turnover: The aversive effects of decreased identity, poor interpersonal communication, and learned helplessness. J Health Commun. 2015;20(10):1155–65.
Walker S, Rossi D, Anastasi J, Gray-Ganter G, Tennent R. Indicators of undergraduate nursing students’ satisfaction with their learning journey: An integrative review. Nurs Educ Today. 2016;43:40–8.
Ford K, Courtney-Pratt H, Marlow A, Cooper J, Williams D, Mason R. Quality clinical placements: The perspectives of undergraduate nursing students and their supervising nurses. Nurs Educ Today. 2016;37:97–102.
Milton-Wildey K, Kenny P, Parmenter G, Hall J. Educational preparation for clinical nursing: The satisfaction of students and new graduates from two Australian universities. Nurs Educ Today. 2014;34(4):648–54.
Trede F, Macklin R, Bridges D. Professional identity development: A review of the higher education literature. Stud High Educ. 2011;37(3):365–84.
Bord Altranais agus Cnáimhseachais na hÉireann Nursing and Midwifery Board of Ireland. Nurse registration programmes standards and Recommitments. 4th edition. Dublin: Nursing and Midwifery Board of Ireland; 2016.
Baldwin A, Mills J, Birks M, Budden L. Role modeling in undergraduate nursing education: An integrative literature review. Nurs Educ Today. 2014;34(6):e18–26.
Worthington M, Salamonson Y, Weaver R, Cleary M. Predictive validity of the Macleod Clark professional identity scale for undergraduate nursing students. Nurs Educ Today. 2013;33(3):187–91.
Department of Health. A policy on the development of graduate to advanced nursing and midwifery practice. Dublin: Department of Health; 2019.
Department of Health. Sláintecare action plan 2019. Dublin: Department of Health; 2019.
Doody O, Bailey ME, Hennessy T. Nature and extent of intellectual disability nursing research in Ireland: a scoping review to inform health and health service research. BMJ Open. 2021;11(10):e051858.
McKenzie E. The uniqueness of disability nursing. Kai Tiaki: Nurs New Zealand. 2019;25(3):38–38.
Wilson NJ, Collison J, Feighan SJ, Howie V, Whitehead L, Wiese M, O’Reilly K, Jaques H, Lewis P. A national survey of nurses who care for people with intellectual and developmental disability. Aust J Adv Nurs. 2020;37(3):4–12.
Murray GC, McKenzie K, Metcalfe D, Whelan K, Murray AL. Exploring the relative importance of factors that influence the job retention of social care staff working in intellectual disability services. Brit J Learn Disabil. 2021;00:1–6.
No funding was obtained for this study.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
The study was approved by the Education and Health Science Research Ethics Committee (2019_05_08_EHS) of the University of Limerick, Ireland. Participant’s received a detailed information sheet prior to agreeing to participate in the study and provided written informed consent and the study was conducted in accordance with the relevant guidelines and regulations.
Consent for publication
Consent for publication of data from participant’s was obtained as part of the written informed consent process and attention was drawn to this in the detailed information sheet provided prior to participant’s deciding to become involved in the study.
The researchers declare that there is no conflict of interests regarding the publication of this paper.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Doody, O., Meskell, P., Murphy-Tighe, S. et al. Fourth year intellectual disability student nurses’ journey and future work intention: a qualitative study. BMC Nurs 21, 220 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12912-022-01007-9
- Intellectual disability