A study on the “community-hospital-community” model of community nursing practice teaching for undergraduate nursing students

Abstract

Objective

To improve the quality of community nursing teaching practice and cultivate undergraduate nursing students who meet the quality accreditation standards of our nursing profession, and to explore the establishment of an undergraduate nurse practice model.

Methods

Using the methods of literature review, survey, expert consultation, and discussion, we established the steps and contents of community practice teaching for undergraduate nursing students, and implemented them for the students of Grades 2014, 2015, and 2016, and evaluated the “community-hospital-community” practice model through various forms, such as student self-evaluation, faculty evaluation, exit examination, and evaluation by certified experts.

Result

A three-stage community nursing practice model of “community-hospital-community” was established for undergraduate nursing students. After three stages of practice, nursing undergraduates successfully passed the practical assessments and achieved excellent grades in each stage that met the requirements of the training program. In the first stage (community probation), community probation emphasizes a fundamental understanding of the community, using free clinics, health education, and home visits as entry points to effectively cultivate students’ job competence and proficiency in nursing operations and nurse-patient communication skills. In the second stage (internship in the hospital), through nursing internships in various systems, students are trained to integrate theoretical knowledge with practical skills and consolidate their understanding of fundamental knowledge, theory, and techniques. They are capable of preventing, diagnosing, intervening, and providing health education for common, frequent, urgent and critical complications in various clinical systems. They can formulate nursing plans and implement whole-person care. In the third stage (returning to the community for internship), students can master basic skills such as nursing operations and patient communication skills, and then they can enter the community internship.

Conclusion

The community nursing practice model of “community- hospital- community” for undergraduate nursing students can systematically train undergraduate nursing students’ ability to work in the community.

Introduction

Due to the increasing demand for services, aging population, prolonged life expectancy and global financial challenges, the provision of health care services is becoming more and more complicated. The current model relies heavily on secondary health care rather than hospitals, resulting in a lot of waiting time and obstacles to access to health services [1,2,3]. Therefore, community nursing plays an increasingly prominent role in medical and health services. Community nurses [4] refer to professional nursing technicians who are engaged in community nursing work in community health institutions and other relevant medical institutions. They are the main force in community health care, and training community nurses is one of the important ways to improve the community medical service team and meet the community medical needs [5]. In 2016, China’s National Health and Family Planning Commission issued the National Nursing Career Development Plan (2016–2020), which explicitly proposed to accelerate the development of community nursing [6, 7], community nurses play an important role in the health of the population, and they are an important force to improve the level of community nursing services, and to gradually establish a long-term care service system through the extension of community nursing services to home care services.

The registration system of community nursing in foreign countries started early and is relatively perfect. Most foreign community nurses have bachelor’s degree, master’s degree or above [8], and the cultivation of high-level community nursing talents is more professional [9,10,11,12]. According to foreign research reports, the education of nursing students abroad emphasizes the multi-level and multi-field of curriculum [13]; Pay attention to the novelty and practicality of teaching methods, emphasize group participation, academic-community partnership mode, mixed learning mode and “Internet Plus teaching” mode to promote community nursing teaching [14, 15], so as to cultivate nursing students’ ability to solve problems independently and promote critical reflection. In terms of community clinical experience training, the United States and other countries often adopt the mode of interspersed practice for the arrangement of practical courses, and theoretical courses and practical courses are held at the same time [16]. In terms of continuing education for community nurses, the United States requires community nurses to regularly participate in continuing education and training for community nurses, so as to improve their nursing knowledge and skills and strengthen their comprehensive ability of community health management [17].

In contrast, although the school education of community nursing in China is basically the same as that in foreign countries, community nursing education in China started late, mainly in the vocational education of junior college and secondary school. At present, most community nurses are transferred from clinical hospitals, and they only have several years of working experience in some clinical departments, but they do not have the ability of community general nursing, so it is difficult to meet the needs of community nursing jobs [18,19,20]. However, the nursing graduates trained by the school are more inclined to work in hospitals and less likely to engage in community nursing [21]. Although community nursing has become a compulsory course of undergraduate nursing education in China. However, due to the late start of teaching, it is still in the stage of exploration and reform of teaching methods. Students’ concern and interest in community nursing learning are low [22, 23], and they lack initiative, and systematic research on practical teaching, and the practical teaching link is even weaker, which should arouse the common concern of schools and community nursing teaching practice bases.

The Code of Practice for Undergraduate Nursing Programs states that the teaching objectives of Community Nursing are: to complete the theoretical study and practical teaching of this course under the teaching guidance of professional teachers, to solidify students’ theoretical knowledge, to develop students’ abilities in community assessment and family health assessment, to improve students’ comprehensive clinical abilities, and to enable students to carry out unique community nursing and community health education.

Undergraduate nursing students need to go through four years study. Internships between classes in the third grade are an important part of nursing clinical education and an important way for nursing undergraduates to acquire professional knowledge, skills, attitudes, and behaviors that professional nurses must possess. This study aims to improve the post competence of undergraduate nursing students and constructs a new teaching model of “community-hospital-community”. In the first stage, the students went to the community for three times in the second semester of their junior year, each time for four hours; in the second stage, they went to the hospital from the sixth semester to the seventh semester for a total of 40 weeks. In the third stage, they returned to the community hospital again at the end of the seventh semester. It is hoped that this model can improve the teaching of community nursing, improve the post competence of undergraduate nursing students, and cultivate professional talents for the development of community nursing in China.

Materials and methods

Participants of study

Undergraduate nursing students in 2014, a total of 117 students. We started this model for the first time in 2017 and collected the data of junior students in that year (students in Grade 2014), and continued to verify this practice model every year since then.

Implementation time of model

In the first stage (community probation), students enter the community for three times in the next semester of junior year (the fifth semester), with four hours each time; In the second stage, the students enter the hospital internship from the sixth semester to the seventh semester, for a total of 40 weeks. In the third stage, the students returned to the community for internship at the end of the seventh semester. Students in Grade 2015 and Grade 2016 also implemented this model in the same semester.

“Community-hospital-community” teaching mode location and personnel

The sites in the first and third stages–Longjiang Community Health Service Center

Longjiang Community Health Service Center, as a practical teaching center, is an excellent demonstration community located in Linghe District, Jinzhou City, Liaoning Province. The community covers an area of 1.36 square kilometers, with a population of 36,000. There are 7 communities in total, and the business area of the community center is more than 2,000 square meters. It has complete practical teaching facilities, including a general clinic, preventive health care department, planned immunization department (vaccination room), rehabilitation physiotherapy department, health education room, health information management room, and family planning department. The center adheres to the service concept of “based on the community, facing the society, giving priority to prevention and paying equal attention to the center”, strengthens the connotation construction, creates the characteristics of traditional Chinese medicine, and constantly improves and improves the service ability of “traditional Chinese medicine” in community health service centers. While fulfilling the “six-in-one” function of community health, it is guided by the needs of residents, strengthens the characteristics of traditional Chinese medicine, organically combines the development of traditional Chinese medicine with other work, and provides effective, positive, and integrated services for residents within its jurisdiction Figure 1 shows the location of the practice.

The sites in the second stage–the First Affiliated Hospital of Jinzhou Medical University

The First Affiliated Hospital of Jinzhou Medical University, founded in 1946, is a national large-scale comprehensive third-class first-class hospital and one of the three regional medical centers in Liaoning Province, which undertakes the tasks of medical treatment, teaching, scientific research, preventive health care, emergency and emergency treatment in Liaoning Province. As a teaching hospital, it undertakes the training of undergraduate college students and graduate students. The hospital regards the cultivation of medical humanities and professionalism as the basis of professional education; Clinical practice ability and clinical thinking training are the key points of professional training. Figure 1 shows the location of practice.

Fig. 1

The location of practice

Syllabus revision experts

Practical teaching is led by the school’s Academic Affairs Office, which invites two experts from outside the school, four teaching managers, three full-time teachers from the teaching and research department, and four external teachers from the community to determine the content and steps of practical teaching through the Delphi back-to-back expert consultation method [24,25,26].

Arrangement of community nursing teaching content and methods in the “community-hospital-community” teaching model

Theoretical study

The theoretical teaching of “Community Nursing” is arranged in the sixth semester of enrollment, and the third edition of Li Chunyu [27] is used as the theoretical teaching content, which is taught by the teachers of professional courses in the teaching and research department.

Practical teaching methods and steps

The first stage: community probation

The teaching content mainly includes 4 h of environment introduction, service content, service characteristics, service methods, health file establishment, etc., 4 h of health education, home visit, home care, etc. Community activities probation 3–4 times, using the community as the venue, during the school period to carry out 3–4 times of community volunteer medical and health education activities. The internship results will be evaluated by the internship report (Table 1).

Table 1 The first stage: community probation

The second stage: internship in the hospital

Internship in a hospital is a mandatory requirement for nursing students in China to graduate. The school requires students to enter clinical practice for 40 weeks. It needs to be trained by departments of 13 major disease systems. The training scheme of each department is complete and feasible (Table 2).

Table 2 The second stage: internship in the hospital

The third stage: returning to the community for internship

After 40 weeks of clinical internship, students will have 2 weeks of community internship teaching for a total of 10 days. On the day of entering the department, they will have an induction education, which includes: an overview of the community, the purpose and significance of the internship, the requirements and methods of the internship, the management system of the internship, and the final assessment system. The students were arranged to enter the department by the academic affairs department and were taught one-on-one or one-on-two by external teachers (Table 3).

Table 3 The third stage: returning to the community for internship

Personnel and system in three stages

The requirements of teachers needed in the three stages are shown in Table 4.

Table 4 Personnel and system in three stages

Evaluation of teaching in three stages

The first stage: community probation

The probation teaching evaluation is in the form of probation report, and the score is given by the standardized requirements of our probation, with a full score of 100 points and a passing score of 60. See the Supplementary Material 1 for the scoring form (Supplementary Material 1: Probation report).

The second stage: internship in the hospital

All departments of the hospital make a final evaluation after the students’ internship, and assess them according to the learning content (Table 2), which is divided into qualified and unqualified.

The third stage: returning to the community for internship

Table 5 is the assessment content of community internship. The final written test score of community practice takes the average score of the test papers of five departments.The corresponding content is in Supplementary Material 2, 3, 4 and 5.(Supplementary Material 2: Daily work performance rating of students by supervising teachers; Supplementary Material 3: Home visits; Supplementary Material 4: Chronic disease community management program score; Supplementary Material 5: Examination questions for community internship).

Table 5 The assessment content of community internship

Graduation post-competency evaluation

Post competency [19, 28] refers to the abilities and qualities that a person needs to perform successfully in a particular position or occupation. It includes an individual’s knowledge, skills, experience, and abilities. Simply put, it is the qualification and ability to assume the post. China’s undergraduate nursing education focuses on the cultivation of professional talents, and job competence after entering the workplace is particularly important, not only to test the professional skills of nursing students but also to reflect whether a school’s training program is reasonable and feasible.

The unstructured interview method [29,30,31] and semi-open-ended questionnaire were used to interview and survey the study participants. The questionnaire mainly included 7 major topics such as community nursing knowledge and skills, observation and judgment, interpersonal communication and cooperation, empathy and responsibility, role awareness and transition, self-behavior and cognition, research, and innovation ability, etc., in which each topic contained 10 sub-questions. Each theme contains 10 sub-questions, using a 4-point scale of “strongly agree”, “agree”, “disagree” and “strongly disagree”, with scores of 4, 3, 2, and 1, and the total score was standardized by a percentage system to calculate the post competency [32, 33].

Learning goals

From the perspective of KAP [34] (Knowledge, Attitude, and Practice), the learning goals of this study are as follows. Familiar with the workflow of community residents’ health file management department, traditional Chinese medicine physiotherapy rehabilitation department, general clinic, maternal and child health care department, and vaccination department, learn the establishment and management methods of health files, understand the efficacy and usage of common Chinese medicines, be familiar with common diseases and frequently-occurring diseases in the community, and master the health care knowledge of women and children and the theoretical knowledge of children’s immunization. Establish a “people-oriented” service concept and implement the belief in humanistic care. Master basic nursing operations (intramuscular injection, vaccination, oxygen inhalation, drug configuration for skin test, etc.), publicize the knowledge of traditional Chinese medicine and the importance of primary health care, participate in a family visit, participate in a community nursing evaluation, a health education, and a chronic disease management. Finally, to achieve the improvement of post competence and course performance. Finally, to improve the understanding of the community nursing course, and improve the post competence.

Teaching quality control and evaluation

Personnel organization setting

Organizational chart of teaching as shown in Figs. 2 and 3. Figure 2 shows the teaching structure of Longjiang Community Health Service Center, in the first and third stages. Figure 3 shows the teaching structure of the first affiliated hospital of Jinzhou Medical University in the second stage of practice.

Fig. 2

Organizational chart of teaching (Longjiang Community Health Service Center)

Fig. 3

Organizational chart of teaching (The First Affiliated Hospital of Jinzhou Medical University)

Results

We invited Professor Zhao Yue from the School of Nursing of Tianjin Medical University and Professor Guo Guifang from the School of Nursing of Peking University as community nursing experts to visit and view the field. Both experts eventually responded favorably to this aspect of community practice teaching. In addition to the field investigation of several experts, we also have four evaluation indicators, namely, probation score, internship score, post competence, and degree satisfaction of internship (Table 6).

Probation score

The probation scores of students in Grade 2014, Grade 2015 and Grade 2016 are 92.4±4.9, 93.6±5.1 and 94.6±3.6 respectively.

Results of the third stage

All students passed the practical assessments in the third stage.

Internship score

The internship scores of students in Grade 2014, Grade 2015 and Grade 2016 are 87.5 ± 6.8, 89.5 ± 7.4, and 88.3 ± 8.2, respectively. Compared with the scores of students in Grade 2013 who did not adopt this mode of internship (78.4 ± 5.7), they all improved.

Post competence

After the practice, the scores of students’ post competence were all improved (87.6 ± 6.2 VS 91.2 ± 8.6/88.3 ± 5.7 VS 93.5 ± 7.9/86.2 ± 7.1 VS 94.4 ± 7.4), and the difference was statistically significant (P < 0.05).

Degree Satisfaction of internship

After the internship, students and teachers rated their satisfaction with the learning process, and all evaluations were anonymous. Likert’s five-level scoring method was adopted, from very dissatisfied to very satisfied [35]. Satisfaction = (Satisfied + Very Satisfied)/Total *100%.

Table 6 Comparison of various indicators of probation and internship

Discussion

In our research, the results showed that nursing undergraduates have successfully passed the three stages of study and assessment, and the three-stage teaching practice mode of “community-hospital-community” has achieved good results. Students’ satisfaction degree is at a high level, and their academic performance has also improved. The evaluation results of post competence before and after practice showed that there was a significant difference in the total score of post competence before and after practice teaching (P < 0.05). In addition, we invited Professor Zhao Yue from the School of Nursing of Tianjin Medical University and Professor Guo Guifang from the School of Nursing of Peking University as community nursing experts to visit and view the field. Both experts eventually responded favorably to this aspect of community practice teaching.

The nursing discipline in developed countries started early, developed quickly, and relatively mature, with the trend of integration and comprehensiveness, and focusing on the combination of theory and practice which has formed a more mature clinical practice skills training model [36]. The biggest difference between developed countries and our country in the undergraduate nursing students’ practical skills training mode is the difference in internship. To improve the practical skills of students, some foreign institutions advocate early contact with the clinic, with more arrangements for laboratory courses, apprenticeships, and internship courses. The United States attaches particular importance to the practical skills training of nurses, such as the University of Pittsburgh, from the first year of enrollment. For example, the University of Pittsburgh from the first year of enrollment began to contact clinical practice, in addition to the theoretical and practical courses during the school year, but also according to the objectives of the curriculum to arrange clinical practice, from the shallow to the deep, and gradually increase the practical skills of students [37]; Northeastern University, Boston, in the community nursing program focuses on the cultivation of “multidisciplinary skills”, the proportion of community nursing practice also Northeastern University in Boston focuses on the development of “multidisciplinary skills” in the community nursing program, and the proportion of community nursing practice is up to 50%, which plays a key role in the development of community nurses’ practice skills [38].

In addition, nursing schools abroad provide opportunities for students to participate in community nursing practice under the auspices of some organizations or in collaboration with academic nursing societies, to consolidate theoretical knowledge and develop the competencies required for community nursing. For example, the University of Beirut has a 16-week, 9-hours-per-week community practice program. In this program, students are required to make home visits to designated families for 2 h per week. The University of Missouri Sinclair School of Nursing has offered a 2-week community-based nursing practice abroad program for selected undergraduate students since 2011, in which students enhance their adaptability, cultural awareness, and problem-solving skills.

At present, most of the training of nursing students in China still adopts the traditional “three-stage” course distribution model, that is, including the basic professional and public courses in the early stage, the middle stage of the comprehensive nursing courses, and the late stage of the clinical internship in the hospital [39]. Although there are occasional short-term practicums in community hospitals near the school, they are mostly bystander-oriented with few hands-on opportunities. Moreover, in the past 20 years, we have neglected the irreplaceable status work of community nursing as a community health service, the development of community nursing is relatively late, and there is no systematic and comprehensive training of community nurses in community nursing knowledge and practical skills [40]. If we copy the foreign model, it is not in line with our actual situation, so we should change the strategy from the source of talent training.

The three-stage community nursing practice model of “community-hospital-community” we have constructed for undergraduate nursing students, with classroom apprenticeship, community activities, and graduation internship as the main axes, fosters the students’ concepts of serving the community and grass-roots level and establishes the concepts of Chinese and Western medicine of prevention as the mainstay of prevention and the treatment of future illnesses to cultivate undergraduate nurses with the basic ability of engaging in community nursing. Talents. The internship and activities focus on the basic understanding of the community, with free clinics, health education, and family visit as the entry point, and effectively cultivate students’ job competence. At the end of the internship in the hospital, when the students master the basic skills of nursing operation, nurse-patient communication skills, etc., they will be allowed to enter into the community internship, and arrange the internship for 2 weeks with the community functional department as the basic unit, and set up the graduation internship mode with the community functional department as the unit, and cultivate basic community nurses according to the content and requirements of the internship. The content and requirements of the internship training of community nurses in the basic work capacity, the training process are mainly rules and regulations to regulate the apprenticeship internship students, through the subjective and objective assessment of students, assessment focus on the development of students’ job competence. In addition, nursing teachers can optimize the construction of nursing training mode through practice. Firstly, professional teachers can continuously improve their teaching and research ability by guiding students in community internship activities, participating in nursing service, education and research in community nursing service centers; carrying out teaching reform, formulating opinions on strengthening the implementation of teaching methods reform and put forward implementation plans for education and teaching research; thirdly, optimize the curriculum system according to the needs of community nursing training.

Based on the above findings, we put forward the following suggestions. First, improve relevant policies and systems to improve the level of community nursing education. Second, change the teaching concept of community nursing and innovate the training mode of community nursing talents by using various teaching methods. Thirdly, the content and standard of teaching evaluation should be formulated to improve the quality of nursing teaching. Fourth, strengthen the construction of a practice base and cultivate professional comprehensive ability.

Limitations

First, in the process of practice, we also encountered some problems: the community activities organization link is larger, we usually select weeks off, and discuss with the student management community clinic, and family visits, due to more people, some students cannot be present; community practice base personnel quality varies, community nursing practice teaching staff nursing origin personnel less, some community clinicians still need to strengthen the teaching training. Second, the leave request and cancellation system of students sometimes cannot be complied with, and the home visit/health education objects cannot be executed as planned due to unexpected circumstances, which need to be further improved. Third, the participants in this study are junior students who entered the school in 2014. The first time to collect data was in 2017, which is slightly far from the current time. But every year after that, we continue to track the data of new junior students, hoping that this model can help improve our grades and understand the course.

Conclusions

Through the practice mode of “community-hospital-community”, our result shows that the graduation performance has improved compared with that of undergraduate nursing students in Grade 2014, Grade 2015, and Grade 2016. And the total score of post competence has also improved before and after practical teaching. The community nursing practice model of “community- hospital- community” for undergraduate nursing students can systematically train undergraduate nursing students’ ability to work in the community.